2025 Jobs Report

Together with our higher education and employer partners, we’re proving what’s possible when you empower the next generation of leaders with the skills, networks, experiences, and confidence necessary to launch a strong career.

Anahi Garcia
City College of New York
Operations Manager Assistant, Research Foundation of City College of New York
Kyle James | Put You on Stage
Spring 2023 Fellow

What does this report cover?

Steve Lee
San José State University
Public Relations Assistant, Cook Country Sheriff's Office
Joe Mazza Photography (San Francisco, CA)
Spring 2023 Fellow
Alongside our dedicated partners, Braven’s ambition is to help rebuild the middle class and revitalize the American Dream.

By 2032, our ambition is to work with 80,000-100,000 students, empowering 25,000 new students through the course each year.

To date, we’ve worked with 12,000 Fellows in many communities across the country.

In this report, we highlight the stories of the incredibly talented, diverse undergraduate students we have the privilege of working with as we dive into two questions that assess Braven’s impact:
1
Are our Fellows getting strong jobs that put them on the path to the American Dream?
2
Are we supporting Fellows on the path to internships and college completion?

Why our work matters

Zokyah Green
The City College of New York
Graduate Student, Masters in School Counseling,
Brooklyn College
Kyle James | Put You on Stage
Fall 2022 Fellow

Nationally, only about 30% of 1.4 million low-income or first-generation college students who enroll in college each year will graduate and secure a strong first job or enter graduate school.1

Low-income or first-generation college student enrollees each year
1.4 million
~400k
~ 1 million
GRADUATE AND SECURE A STRONG JOB OR ENTER GRADuate SCHOOL
ARE NOT ON THE PATH TO THE AMERICAN Dream
~70%
Not on Path To The American Dream
That’s more than one million students every single year who aren’t on the path to the American Dream.

Mission

In collaboration with our higher education and employer partners, Braven empowers promising college students with the skills, confidence, experiences, and networks necessary to transition from college to strong economic opportunities, which lead to meaningful careers and lives of impact.

VISION

The next generation of leaders will emerge from everywhere.

The Braven Model

Braven empowers promising college students on their paths toward quality economic opportunities through a semester-long, cohort-based course—developed with input from our higher education partners and faculty—and support that extends beyond the course, continuing through six months after college graduation.

In our core higher education model, students take the course for credit. Students who come through BravenX via college success organizations receive a financial stipend in lieu of credit.

Our Partners

ARE Our FELLOWS Securing QUALitY Career Outcomes THAT PUT THEM ON THE PATH TO THE AMERICAN Dream?

Shveta Ram
San José State University
Financial Analyst, Lockheed Martin Space
Joe Mazza Photography (San Francisco, CA)
Fall 2022 Fellow

CCNY Braven Fellows aTTAIN Quality Opportunities After College

George Draper, III
San José State University
Operations Manager, Amazon
Joe Mazza Photography (San Francisco, CA)
Spring 2024 Fellow
In 2024, 980 Braven Fellows graduated from core partner schools.

This year across our core model higher education partner sites, quality opportunity attainment ranges from 45% to 70%. As we scale, we will continue to address these differences to ensure that Fellows remain on the path to economic mobility.

We are proud of the achievements of our graduates who hail from a diverse set of institutions and are launching their careers into local labor markets that vary in industry composition and stages of economic recovery.  

This new class is outpacing their peers nationally in quality outcome attainment by 21 percentage points (61% vs 40%) within six months of graduation.7,8  

Eighty-four percent of the Class of 2024 of Braven graduates were employed overall or enrolled in graduate school within six months of college graduation.

In 2024, 147 Braven Fellows graduated from City College of New York.

45% graduates secured quality opportunities, and 84% are employed overall or enrolled in graduate school.

45%
2024 CCNY BRAVEN GRADUATES7
+
+8
percentage points
37%
Graduates with a Bachelor’s Degree from Peer Institutions
with a Similar Concentration of Pell Grant Recipients (2012-2021)9
48%
GRADUATES NATIONALLY WITH A  BACHELOR'S DEGREE (2012-2021)9
CCNY BRAVEN Class of 2024 Demographics10
People of color
24%
black
42%
latinx/a/o
28%
asian American,
Pacific Islander
Students from low-income Backgrounds
First-Generation college students

The Strength of roles our CCNY braven 2024 Graduates secured

Of the 147 Braven Fellows who graduated from CCNY in 2024,
84%
Are employed or enrolled in graduate school
66%
sECURED QUALITY
OR PATHWAY OUTCOMES
2024 CCNY Braven Graduates7, 8
45%
21%
17%
17%
Quality Roles or graduate school
Pathway Roles
Non-Quality roles
Unemployed
How we define quality economic opportunities:
Quality role:

a full-time role that requires a bachelor’s degree and includes some combination of promotion pathways, employee benefits, and a market-competitive starting salary, or enrollment in graduate school

Pathway role:

a role that does not require a bachelor’s degree but helps students’ financial sustainability, is aligned with career interests, and will likely lead to more career-accelerating possibilities through skill development

Non-quality role:

a role that does not require a bachelor’s degree, offers limited runway to additional career-accelerating opportunities, and is not aligned with students’ career interests

CCNY Braven Graduates Outearning New Yorkers of All Ages

The Robin Hood Poverty Tracker, a long running study by Columbia University and the Robin Hood Foundation documenting the dynamics of poverty in New York, found that only 45% of New York adults earned moderate to high incomes (greater than $44K) in 2023.13

Individuals in this income bracket are less likely to experience psychological distress, health problems, and hardship overall.13

60% of CCNY Braven 2024 graduates are earning moderate to high-income salaries in their first job out of college, 15 percentage points higher than the New York average.
60%
CCNY Braven 2024 GRADUATES EARNING MODERATE TO HIGH-INCOME SALARIES ($44K or more)
+
+15
percentage points
45%
ADULT NEW YORK RESIDENTS EARNING MODERATE TO HIGH-INCOME SALARIES ($44K or more)

Braven Fellows on a Thriving Path In Today's Economy

Lance Simon
Rutgers University-Newark
Tax Consultant, Deloitte
Joshua Christie | Purpose Portraits
Fall 2022 Fellow
When students develop career-readiness skills, networks, confidence, and experiences, the American Dream is attainable within semesters.

74% of our graduates nationally are already out earning their parents at the same age in their first job out of college.14

By comparison, by age 30, Americans have a 50-50 shot of out-earning their parents.15

Most popular industries for Braven Fellows14

Education
Technology
Non-Profit
Health
Banking & Finance
Camila Maroso Berton
National Louis University
Senior Administrative Assistant of Appraisals, CIBC US
Chris Joyce
Spring 2023 Fellow

Building Career Wealth & Health

A high quality first job helps individuals build long-term wealth and health.

Braven defines a strong first job as one that requires a bachelor’s degree and is full-time, and also includes some combination of promotion pathways, employee benefits, and a market-competitive starting salary.

Six months post-graduation, Braven Fellows in the Class of 2024 are earning above the national average salary of all early career college graduates.

$47,898
Mean salary of employed 2024 CCNY Braven graduates in the first 6 months after college graduation
+$5.4k

Compared to a national average of $42,537 of recent college graduates aged 23-24 who were employed in 202316

$55,977
Mean salary of full-time employed 2024 CCNY Braven graduates in the first 6 months after college graduation
+$6.3k

Compared to a national average of $49,630 of recent college graduates aged 23-24 who worked full-time in 202316

Recent Braven Graduates

ARE IN ROLES ALIGNED WITH THEIR LONG-TERM CAREER INTERESTS14

HAVE A JOB WITH EMPLOYER PROVIDED
BENEFITS14

The Braven equation in Action

Erica Pino
Rutgers University-Newark
Graduate Student, Master of Business and Science in Computer and Information Science, Rutgers University-Newark
Joshua Christie | Purpose Portraits
Spring 2024 Fellow
With Braven’s help, Erica Pino built the foundation to get on the path to the American promise.
Networks

Paired with Leadership Coach Maggie Chapoteau, a seasoned operations management professional whose experience spans multiple industries of telecom, law, and finance, who provided Erica with 60 hours of mentorship

skills

The Braven experience
equipped Erica with
5 key career competencies:

Self-driven leadership • Working in teams • Problem solving • Networking and communicating • Operating and managing

Experiences

After the Braven course, Erica secured a high-quality internship:

Research Assistant Intern, Rutgers-Child Study Center

Confidence

“My Leadership Coach was incredibly supportive, always open to answering my questions about the professional world. Hearing experiences from peers and other mentors also helped me develop new skills and fresh perspectives.”

Career-Ready
College
Graduate
With Braven’s help, Erica Pino built the foundation to get on the path to the American promise.
Networks
Paired with Leadership Coach Maggie Chapoteau, a seasoned operations management professional whose experience spans multiple industries of telecom, law and finance, who provided Erica with 60 hours of mentorship.
skills
The Braven experience
equipped Erica with
5 key career competencies:

Self-driven leadership • Working in teams • Problem solving • Networking and communicating • Operating and managing
Confidence
“My Leadership Coach was incredibly supportive, always open to answering my questions about the professional world. Hearing experiences from peers and other mentors also helped me develop new skills and fresh perspectives.”
Experiences
After the Braven course, Erica secured a high-quality internship:
Research Assistant Intern,
Rutgers-Child Study Center

Digging Deeper: Top Three Trends influencing CCNY Braven Fellow Outcomes

Trend 1
The Journey of the Class of 2024
Trend 2
NYC unemployment rate higher than national average
Trend 3
When Fellows Take Braven During College Matters
Trend 1

The Journey of the Class of 2024

The Class of 2024 had a unique and difficult undergraduate experience. They began college in a pandemic and graduated into a cooling labor market.
2020-2021
Amid the Class of 2024's freshman year, the COVID-19 pandemic disrupts higher education and student experiences
The percentage of students enrolled in at least one distance education course doubled.2
36%
Fall 2019
75%
Fall 2020
2021- 2023
During the middle of the Class of 2024's higher education experience, job and internship opportunities recover
In March 2022, job openings
rebounded to the highest level recorded since 2000: 12 million openings.3
7 mil
FEB 2020
12mil
March 2022
The Braven Class of 2024 had the highest rate of internship attainment out of the past 6 graduating classes largely due to increases in internship opportunities post-pandemic.4
2024
As the Class of 2024 graduates, the labor market cools off, hiring slows down, and unemployment increases
The newest job seekers, those aged 20 to 24, saw a 1.2 percentage point increase in their unemployment rate -- 4x the growth in the unemployment rate across all workers.5, 6
+1.2
Percentage points
OCT 2023
6%
OCT 2024
7.2%
Unemployment rate for Ages 20 to 24
+0.3
Percentage points
OCT 2023
3.8%
OCT 2024
4.1%
Unemployment rate for all Ages

The Journey of the Class of 2024

The Class of 2024 had a unique and difficult undergraduate experience.They began college in a pandemic and graduated into a cooling labor market.
2020-2021
Amid the Class of 2024's freshman year, the COVID-19 pandemic
disrupts higher education
and student experiences
The percentage of students enrolled in at least one distance education course doubled.2
36%
Fall 2019
75%
Fall 2020
2021- 2023
During the middle of the
Class of 2024's higher education experience, job and internship opportunities recover
In March 2022, job openings
rebounded to the highest level recorded since 2000: 12 million openings.3
7 mil3
FEB 2020
12mil
March 2022

The Braven Class of 2024 had the highest rate of internship attainment out of the past 6 graduating classes largely due to increases in internship opportunities post-pandemic.4

2024
As the Class of 2024 graduates,
the labor market cools off,
hiring slows down, and unemployment increases
The newest job seekers, those aged 20 to 24, saw a 1.2 percentage point increase in their unemployment rate -- 4x the growth in the unemployment rate across all workers.5, 6
+1.2
Percentage points
OCT 2023
6%
OCT 2024
7.2%
Unemployment Rate for Ages 20 To 24
+0.3
Percentage points
OCT 2023
3.8%
OCT 2024
4.1%
Unemployment Rate for All Ages
Trend 2
NYC Unemployment Rate Higher Than National Average

As of October 2024, the NYC unemployment rate was 5.3%, 1.2 percentage points higher than the national unemployment rate of 4.1%.11, 12

Recent graduates already suffer from underemployment rates higher than college graduates overall.25 

However, new graduates in cities like New York increasingly have to compete with mid-level talent in today's cooling labor market.

5.3%
NYC UNEMPLOYMENT RATE11
+1.2
Percentage Point
Difference
4.1%
National UNEMPLOYMENT RATE12
Trend 3
When Fellows take Braven during college matters.

CCNY Fellows who take Braven as a senior have less time to complete career-accelerating experiences or participate in mentorship before graduating and entering the job market.

93% of the 2024 CCNY Braven graduates took the Braven Accelerator course as a senior.

93%
Seniors
26%
Took the course as a first-semester senior
67%
Took the course as a second-semester senior
6%
Juniors
1%
Freshman, Sophomores, & Graduate Students
57%
CCNY BRAVEN 2024 GRADUATES WHO TOOK BRAVEN AS A JUNIOR24
Quality Outcomes Rate
44%
CCNY BRAVEN 2024 GRADUATES WHO TOOK BRAVEN AS A SENIOR24
Quality Outcomes Rate

ARE We supporting Fellows to secure internships?

Disparities in Access to Internship Completion

Internships help students launch strong careers by helping them:17

Develop skills such as communication, teamwork, problem- solving, and leadership
Gain confidence
or clarity around career goals
Expand professional connections

Signal to employers their acquired knowledge and skills18

Not All Internships Are Created Equal

Paid internships result in better career outcomes.19

+50%
more likely to receive a job offer than unpaid Interns
+15k
in starting salary vs. unpaid interns

The highest quality internships share these characteristics:17, 20

They Are Paid
There is a plan for what the intern is Learning
include relatively high skill tasks with supervision
there is sufficient mentorship and support

Encouraging levels of Internship attainment for Braven Fellows

Bryanna Dawson
Delaware State University
Summer Intern,
National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
Emir Lake
fall 2021 Fellow
For college students, internships serve as critical proof points of experience that open professional doors.
Compared with graduates nationally, CCNY Braven 2024 graduates were 21 percentage points more likely to have at least one internship during their college experience.
69%
CCNY BRAVEN 2024 Graduates
+
+21
percentage points
48%
NATIONAL 2022 GRADUATES21

Braven
Launches Capitol Hill Fellowship

In 2024, Braven & The Sheila Y. Oliver Center for Politics and Race in America (CPRA) at Rutgers University-Newark launched the Capitol Hill Fellowship as an opportunity for Fellows to enter the public service space, particularly on Capitol Hill.

Acquiring an internship in Congress can be especially hard for students from humble beginnings, whether that be tied to financial constraint or networks. Braven’s Capitol Hill Fellowship lowers these barriers by supporting Fellows with applying to internships at Congressional offices, providing Capitol Hill Fellows with eight weeks of housing, professional development, a clothing stipend, and a monthly living stipend. Four Fellows participated in the inaugural year of the Fellowship.

MEET THE SUMMER 2024 INAUGURAL CLass
“I witnessed firsthand how critical policy decisions are made in a collaborative environment, shaping both our nation and my home, New Jersey’s 8th Congressional District.”
Valerie Valle
Interned with Rep. Rob Menendez, Jr. (NJ-8)
“My time on Capitol Hill was transformative, providing insight into the legislative process and daily operations of a congressional office. Engaging with staffers deepened my understanding of how policymaking takes shape.”
Zacharriyah Uddin
Interned with Rep. Mikie Sherrill (NJ-11)
“I had the opportunity to engage in an open conversation with Representative Velázquez, where I learned about her career journey and gained valuable insights and advice.”
Aliyah Saleem
Interned with Rep. Nydia M. Velázquez (NY-07)
"In this role, I had the privilege of collaborating with Rutgers' Center for Politics and Race in America to conduct research and interview influential figures like Senator Laphonza Butler and Representative Bonnie Watson Coleman, gaining valuable insights into their voting records."
Safanya Searcy
Congressional Research Fellow

ARE We supporting Fellows On The Path to college completion?

Nikira Walter
Spelman College
Graduate Student, Doctor of Philosophy, Ph.D., Statistics
Kat Goduco
Spring 2022 Fellow

Encouraging Levels of Persistence
and Graduation

94% of CCNY Braven Fellows are persisting in college or have graduated.23
Nationally, only about 7 in 10 students graduate within six years of college enrollment.22
Braven Fellows, who typically join us during their sophomore or junior year, are persisting and graduating at encouraging rates.
CCNY Fellow
Persistence/Graduation Rate

We Couldn't Do It Without You!

Higher Education Partners & Employer Partners

Higher Education Partners

  • Chicago State University (BravenX)
  • City College of New York – CUNY
  • Delaware State University
  • National Louis University
  • Northern Illinois University
  • Rutgers University - Newark
  • San Francisco State University (launched fall 2024)
  • San José State University
  • Spelman College

BravenX Partners

  • 5 Strong Scholars Foundation
  • Achieve Atlanta
  • Arkansas Commitment
  • Ascend Public Schools
  • Associated Colleges of Illinois
  • Augustana College
  • Breakthrough Kent Denver
  • Carmen Schools of Science & Technology
  • Chicago Scholars
  • Chicago State University
  • City Year Chicago
  • Coney Island Prep Public Schools
  • Cooperman College Scholars
  • Coral Academy of Science Las Vegas
  • Cristo Rey Network
  • DREAM Charter School
  • DSST Public Schools
  • Evanston Scholars
  • Excel Academy Charter School
  • Excellence Community Schools
  • Freedom Preparatory Academy Charter Schools
  • IDEA Public Schools
  • Judson University
  • KIPP Metro Atlanta
  • KIPP Forward
  • KIPP NJ
  • Lehman College
  • LISA Academy
  • National Association for Urban Debate Leagues
  • Newark Youth Career Pathways Program
  • North Central College
  • Noble Schools
  • Rivet School
  • SEEDS
  • The Academy Charter School
  • The Wight Foundation
  • Uncommon Schools
  • Uplift Education
  • UtmostU

Employer Partners
LEAD

(250K+ and programmatic support)

  • Adobe
  • Apollo Opportunity Foundation
  • Atlassian
  • Barclays
  • Capital One
  • Deloitte
  • JP Morgan Chase Foundation
  • LinkedIn
  • Morgan Stanley
  • NBA Foundation
  • Prudential Financial
  • Salesforce

ANCHOR

($100K+ and programmatic support)

  • Brooks Brothers & The Golden Fleece Foundation
  • Cognizant US
  • The College Board
  • UBS

KEYSTONE

($25K+ and programmatic support)

  • Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance
  • Blackbaud
  • BlackRock
  • CIBC Bank USA
  • Clayton, Dubilier & Rice
  • PwC
  • Rakuten International
  • Silver Lake
  • Taco Bell Foundation
  • United Airlines

INNOVATION

($10K+ and programmatic support

  • Neuberger Berman

IMPACT

($5K and/or programmatic support)

  • American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
  • Cadent
  • Eagle Capital Management
  • Hall Capital Partners
  • McKinsey & Company

Supporters (10K+)

  • Akila Grewal
  • Carnegie Corporation of New York
  • Carroll and Milton Petrie Foundation
  • Charles Hayden Foundation
  • Deloitte Foundation
  • Gray Foundation
  • Ken Ohashi & Adam Freed
  • Meghan Mckay & Allen Thorpe
  • Siegel Family Endowment
  • The Carson Family Charitable Trust
  • The Ichigo Foundation
  • The Jeffrey H. and Shari L. Aronson Family Foundation
  • The Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund
  • The Neuberger Berman Foundation
  • A big thank you to our New York City Board of Directors:
  • Roger G. Arrieux, Jr.
  • Kimara Bonhomme
  • Akila Grewal
  • Ken Ohashi

Endnotes

  1. Statistics based on data from the National Center for Education Statistics (2021 digest and 2019 NCES 2019-487), National Student Clearinghouse Research Center’s Transfer & Progress report (Fall 2022), and Third Way’s “The Pell Divide: How Four-Year Institutions are Failing to Graduate Low- and Moderate-Income Students” (2018).
  2. National Center for Education Statistics. "Distance Learning." Fast Facts, U.S. Department of Education,  Accessed 5 Dec. 2024.
  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. "Job Openings Reach Record Highs in 2022 as the Labor Market Recovery Continues." Monthly Labor Review, 2023.
  4. National Association of Colleges and Employers. "Students Recognize the Importance of Gaining Internship Experience." NACEweb.
  5. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Unemployment Rate - College Graduates - Bachelor's Degree, 20 to 24 years. Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED). Accessed 9 Jan. 2025.
  6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. "Unemployment Rate Steady at 4.1 Percent in October 2024." The Economics Daily, 2024.
  7. We have jobs data for 82% of 2024 Braven CCNY graduates
  8. Percentages may or may not add up to 100% due to rounding.
  9. Burning Glass Institute and Strada Institute for the Future of Work, Talent Disrupted: Underemployment, College Graduates, and the Way Forward, 2024. The comparison metric used is percent of employed students who are not underemployed one year after graduation with a bachelor's degree. In the national report, benchmark data for peer institutions was calculated by taking a weighted average of underemployment rates based on the concentration of Pell Grant recipients at Braven's core higher education partners and subtracting this from one. Because CCNY is classified as an institution with a very high concentration of low-income students, the peer benchmark in this report is based on institutions with a very high concentration of low-income students.
  10. Percentage people of color includes all students who identify as any non-White race or ethnicity and/or as a person of color. Race/ethnicity breakdown percentages may not add up to 100% due to specific racial backgrounds shown; they also may add up to more than 100% because students can identify with more than one race or ethnicity.
  11. New York State Department of Labor. State Labor Department Releases Preliminary October 2024 Area Unemployment Rates. 2024. Accessed 9 Jan. 2025.
  12. Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Unemployment Rate Steady at 4.1 Percent in October 2024.” The Economics Daily, 6 Nov. 2024. Accessed 9 Jan. 2025.
  13. Poverty Tracker Research Group at Columbia University. The State of Poverty and Disadvantage in New York City, Volume 7. Robin Hood, Winter 2025.
  14. Inclusive of Braven graduates from 2021-2024.
  15. Chetty, Raj et al. "The Fading American Dream: Trends in Absolute Income Mobility Since 1940." Science, December 2016.
  16. U.S. Census Bureau. American Community Survey. Data filtered by age (AGEP 23-24), income (PINCP > $1), hours worked (WKHP > 35 or WKHP > 0), employment status (ESR Civilian employed, at work), and educational attainment (SCHL Bachelor’s degree).
  17. National Survey of College Internships 2023 Technical Report. Strada Education Foundation. June 2024.
  18. Silva, Erik, et al. What Can We Learn from Longitudinal Studies on the Impacts of College Internships? Center for Research on College-Workforce Transitions, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Apr. 2022.
  19. 2024 NACE Student Survey Report: Four-Year Schools Executive Summary. Sept. 2024.
  20. Deming, David, Joseph B. Fuller, Rachel Lipson, Kerry McKittrick, Ali Epstein, and Emma Catalfamo. Delivering on the Degree: The College-to-Jobs Playbook. Cambridge, MA: Project on Workforce, Malcolm Wiener Center for Social Policy, Harvard Kennedy School, April 2023.
  21. Strada Education Foundation. "From College to Career: Students' Internship Expectations and Experiences." Strada Education Foundation, 17 May 2023, stradaeducation.org/report/fr…ons-and-experiences/.
  22. National comparison is the implied six-year graduation rate for Pell Grant recipients who were full-time, first-time degree/certificate-seeking undergraduate students in the 2017 starting cohort (adjusted) at four-year public Title IV institutions, after accounting for those who persisted from freshman to sophomore year and from sophomore to junior year. Sources for data: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, IPEDS, Winter 2023–24, Graduation Rates component (provisional data);Pitcher, McCall, and Parson, Kelle. “More to the Retention Story: Exploring Second- to Third-Year Retention at 4-Year Colleges and Universities.” American Institutes for Research. July 2023.
  23. Year-over-year persistence/graduation rate is calculated for the 350 CCNY Braven Fellows who took the Accelerator in Spring 2023 or Spring 2024.
  24. 113 seniors and 7 juniors included in sample calculating the quality outcomes rate.
  25. Federal Reserve Bank of New York. "The Labor Market for Recent College Graduates.". Accessed 10 Mar. 2025.